CoinSmart Vs Coinfield: Which Is Better For Canadians In 2026?

How Do CoinSmart And Coinfield Compare, Fact By Fact?

Every row below comes from each company’s own pages and the Canadian registries, checked October 2026. Where a row has no fair winner, it says so.

What Are The Key Differences Between CoinSmart And Coinfield?

How Do You Fund And Cash Out CoinSmart And Coinfield In Canada?

All funding ended. Accounts moved to Bitbuy. Platform closed in 2023. Never send funds to a site using the CoinField name.

What Do CoinSmart And Coinfield Offer Beyond Buying And Selling?

What Happens To Your Money If CoinSmart Or Coinfield Fails?

CoinSmart: This was a merger, not a collapse. CoinSmart's accounts went to Bitbuy, which has since moved to Coinsquare Capital Markets Ltd. and then Robinhood. Log in through Bitbuy with your old CoinSmart email, and never send crypto to an old CoinSmart deposit address, because the addresses changed. If you prefer not to follow the move to Robinhood, withdraw to your own wallet.

Coinfield: Coinfield is the failure case: the platform shut in 2023 without meeting customer withdrawal requests, and the tribunal found it lacked the crypto assets to satisfy them. The sanctions are a permanent Ontario market ban, a CAD 2.4M penalty, CAD 537,034.46 disgorgement and CAD 89,538 costs. No CIPF or other scheme covers crypto, so affected customers should watch for official notices and ignore anyone offering paid recovery.

How Are CoinSmart And Coinfield Treated For Tax In Canada?

CoinSmart: Trades on CoinSmart were dispositions for CRA purposes. Pull your CoinSmart history from your migrated Bitbuy account. Export formats: Not published.

Coinfield: Trades on Coinfield were dispositions for CRA purposes. Keep your records, and speak to an accountant about any crypto you could not withdraw. Export formats: Not published.

Selling, swapping or spending crypto is a disposition for the CRA on any platform. This is not tax advice: see my guide to crypto taxes in Canada.

Which Should You Choose, CoinSmart Or Coinfield?

Choose CoinSmart If

• You want a registered platform that serves Canadians today: Coinbase is our number one replacement, with free Interac e-Transfer funding and a Canadian restricted dealer registration.

Choose Coinfield If

• You want a registered platform that serves Canadians today: Coinbase is our number one replacement, with free Interac e-Transfer funding and a Canadian restricted dealer registration.

What Happened To CoinSmart?

CoinSmart, run by Simply Digital Technologies Inc., stopped operating as a separate exchange after WonderFi moved its client accounts to Bitbuy. WonderFi announced the deal on September 8, 2023, and I could not verify the exact completion date. Its two CSA decisions, the original of October 21, 2021 and an amended one of December 21, 2021, now sit under the CSA's expired decisions.

FINTRAC lists the CoinSmart registration as ceased on September 10, 2024. Today coinsmart.com serves the Bitbuy site with a banner saying Bitbuy is now part of Robinhood. That chain matters: CoinSmart accounts went to Bitbuy, Bitbuy later moved under Coinsquare Capital Markets Ltd., and Robinhood closed its WonderFi purchase on June 1, 2026.

So CoinSmart did not collapse. It was folded into a larger group, and the group is now being folded into Robinhood. Bitbuy has a help article for migrated CoinSmart accounts if you ever need to trace one.

For more detail, see my CoinSmart page. I do not link to CoinSmart for sign-ups, because it is not an option for Canadians.

What Happened To Coinfield?

Coinfield was an Estonia-based exchange, run by Manticore Labs OU with a Canadian arm called Manticore Labs Inc., that began serving Canadians in 2018. It shut down in 2023. In January 2025 Ontario's Capital Markets Tribunal permanently banned its operators from Ontario's markets and ordered a CAD 2.4 million administrative penalty.

The tribunal also ordered CAD 537,034.46 in disgorgement and CAD 89,538 in costs, according to the tribunal decision and advisor.ca. The record shows at least 1,275 Ontario clients held about CAD 2.5 million on the platform at the end of 2022. The regulator's central complaint was that Ontario users could not withdraw.

On the registration side, Coinfield is not on the CSA list of authorized platforms. FINTRAC shows its money services business registration for Manticore Labs OU as revoked on November 10, 2023, and two earlier Coinfield registrations as ceased in 2021 and 2019. It does not appear on the CSA banned list page either, but the tribunal order is the stronger record.

For more detail, see my Coinfield page. I do not link to Coinfield for sign-ups, because it is not an option for Canadians.

What Should CoinSmart And Coinfield Users Use Instead?

Neither platform here is an option, so this match-up comes down to what to use instead. For CoinSmart, my notes point to NDAX: registered Canadian platform with CAD funding and a broad coin list. For Coinfield, my notes point to NDAX: registered Canadian platform; Coinfield was an unregistered Estonia-based operator that failed to let Ontario users withdraw.

What Should You Do If You Still Have Something With CoinSmart Or Coinfield?

CoinSmart: If you held a CoinSmart account, it was migrated to Bitbuy, and Bitbuy's help centre has an article on what to do with a migrated account. Bitbuy itself is now part of Robinhood and is inviting customers to the Robinhood app, so check what you hold there and decide whether you want to stay. Whatever you decide, do not send crypto to an old CoinSmart deposit address.

Coinfield: If you still had money on Coinfield, the Ontario tribunal's January 2025 decision is the public record to read, and it is the place to start for anything about recovery. I would not deposit anything into a site that uses the Coinfield name today. The original platform is gone.

A simple rule applies after any platform change: keep your own records of every purchase, because the CRA treats crypto as a commodity and you need the history for your tax return.